• News
  • Spirituality
    • Dream Interpretation
    • Angel Numbers
    • Tarot
    • Prayers
    • Spells
  • Health
  • Science
  • Celebs
  • Betting

Scientists Tested Natural Language Models To Predict Human Language Judgments


Natural language models may test computational assumptions about how people understand language. A group of scientists from Columbia University in New York, coordinated by Tal Golan and Matthew Siegelman, assessed the model human consistency of several language models using a unique experimental approach: problematic sentence pairs. Two language models differ regarding which sentence is more likely to appear in the real test for each contentious sentence pair. Taking into account nine language models (including n-gram, recurrent neural networks, and transformer models),

The researchers generated hundreds of such contentious sentence pairings by picking phrases from a corpus or synthetically optimizing sentence pairs to be highly controversial and controversial. Human volunteers subsequently made evaluations indicating which of the two terms was more plausible for each couple. Controversial phrase pairings successfully highlighted model flaws and found models most closely matched with human assessments. GPT-2 was the most human-consistent model studied. However, testing showed severe deficiencies in its alignment with human perception.

Natural Language Models

These researchers put nine models from three different classes to the test: n-gram models, recurrent neural networks, and transformers. The Natural Language Toolkit's open source code was used to train the n-gram models. The recurrent neural networks were trained using PyTorch designs and optimization processes. HuggingFace, an open-source repository, was used to build the transformers. They gathered opinions from 100 native English speakers who took an online exam. Participants in each experimental session were asked to determine which statements they would be "more likely to encounter in the world, as either speech or written text" and rate their confidence in their response on a 3 point scale.

Despite the consistency in model ranking between our findings and earlier work, GPT-2's severe failure in predicting human reactions to natural vs. synthetic contentious pairings reveals that GPT-2 does not adequately imitate the computations used in human processing of even short words. This result is somewhat predictable because GPT-2 is an off-the-shelf machine learning model that was not created with human psycholinguistic and physiological features in mind. Even though we found a lot of human inconsistency, a recent GPT-2 study found that almost all of the variations in how people responded to actual words could be explained.

COPYRIGHT_SZ: Published on https://stationzilla.com/natural-language-models/ by Dr. Cooney Blades on 2022-05-13T06:05:07.531Z

Natural And Synthetic Sentences Pairs

The researchers arranged 90 sentence pairings into ten sets of nine sentences each and gave each set to a different group of ten individuals. They calculated the percentage of trials in which the model and the person agreed on which phrase was more likely to assess model-human alignment. All nine language models outperformed chance by predicting human choices for randomly generated natural phrase pairings (50% accuracy). They gave each group of ten individuals a different set of phrase pairs. We statistically analyzed between-model differences while accounting for both people and sentence pairs as random variables using a simple Wilcoxon signed-rank test across the ten participant groups.

A process for synthesizing contentious sentence pairs was created, in which naturally existing sentences serve as initializations for synthetic phrases and reference points that drive sentence synthesis. They started with a naturally occurring statement. They then keep replacing words in the sentence with comments from a predefined vocabulary to make the synthetic sentence less likely to be correct by one language model while ensuring that the synthetic sentence is at least as possible to be accurate by another model.

Human participants rated ten contentious synthetic-sentence pairings for each model pair. They assessed how well each model predicted human sentence choices in all of the controversial synthetic-sentence combinations in which it was one of two models tested.


The tests proved that:

  • There are many ways natural language processing models can generate controversial sentence pairs. They can pick pairs of sentences from a corpus or change natural sentences to make controversial predictions.
  • The contentious sentence pairs make it easy to quickly compare models that seem the same in terms of human consistency.
  • All of the existing natural language processing model classes mistakenly give a high probability to the following non-natural sentences: A simple statement may be modified such that its likelihood according to a specific model does not diminish. Still, as per human judgments, the phrase becomes much less likely.
  • This method of comparing and testing models may give new ideas about which types of models work best with human language perception, and which types of models need to be made in the future.
Share: Twitter | Facebook | Linkedin

About The Authors

Dr. Cooney Blades

Dr. Cooney Blades - I think the correct diagnosis is the most important factor.

Recent Articles

  • How Technology Has Changed The Way We Gamble


    How Technology Has Changed The Way We Gamble

    Do you ever sit back and admire the huge impact technology has had on sports fans betting online? It's quite remarkable, and if you gambled during the time of land-based bookies and casinos, you'd know what we're driving at here.

  • Shocking Video Shows Vagrant Being Choked To Death On NYC Subway


    Shocking Video Shows Vagrant Being Choked To Death On NYC Subway

    Recently, a shocking video shows vagrant being choked to death on NYC subway. The incident has sparked controversy and raised questions about the safety of the city's subway system, as well as the role of social media and the media in shaping public perception.

  • Background On Virginia Legislature Legalizing Sports Betting In Landmark Decision


    Background On Virginia Legislature Legalizing Sports Betting In Landmark Decision

    This past January marked two years since the state of Virginia officially launched sports betting in a groundbreaking decision.

  • US Estimates More Than 20,000 Russian Soldiers Killed In Ukraine War


    US Estimates More Than 20,000 Russian Soldiers Killed In Ukraine War

    The ongoing conflict between Ukraine and Russia has been ongoing for several years. However, the situation has escalated dramatically in recent months. US estimates more than 20,000 Russian soldiers killed in Ukraine war since December of last year.

  • Funny Mike Age - An American Comedian, Rapper, YouTuber, And Social Media Personality


    Funny Mike Age - An American Comedian, Rapper, YouTuber, And Social Media Personality

    Funny Mike is a multi-faceted entertainer who has made a name for himself in the digital age. As an American comedian, rapper, YouTuber, and social media personality, he has gained a significant following on various platforms. Funny Mike age is 26 years old.

  • Having Dreams About Someone Dying - Exploring The Symbolism

    Dream Interpretation

    Having Dreams About Someone Dying - Exploring The Symbolism

    Dreams can often be mysterious and unsettling experiences, and one of the most distressing types of dreams is those where someone dies. Whether it is a loved one or a stranger, having dreams about someone dying can leave us feeling uneasy and worried.

  • 2323 Angel Number - Discovering Balance And Harmony

    Angel Numbers

    2323 Angel Number - Discovering Balance And Harmony

    The 2323 angel number is a powerful symbol that has spiritual significance and is believed to carry a message from the Universe or our angels. This number combination consists of two sets of repeating numbers, 2 and 3, which have unique meanings and energies. The number 2 in 2323 represents balance, harmony, and partnerships, while the number 3 represents creativity, growth, and the ascended masters.

  • Lazarbeam Height And Other Physical Attributes


    Lazarbeam Height And Other Physical Attributes

    LazarBeam is a prominent figure in the world of online gaming and entertainment. As a professional gamer and popular YouTuber, he has amassed a massive following through his engaging content and entertaining personality. He is a physically strong guy. Lazarbeam height is 6 feet and 3 inches.

  • Caleb Coffee Girlfriend - Known For His Engaging And Hilarious Videos


    Caleb Coffee Girlfriend - Known For His Engaging And Hilarious Videos

    Many people want to know about Caleb Coffee girlfriend and lifestyle. So in this article, we will delve deeper into the life and career of this rising star to know about Caleb Coffee girlfriend and family and explore the secrets of his success.

  • 1255 Twin Flame Meaning And What It Can Tell You

  • Dream Mother Dying - Coping With Grief

  • Dreaming About Deceased Person - Understanding The Significance

  • Russia In Disarray As Ukraine Gears Up For Counteroffensive

  • Restorative Yoga As A Stress Reduction Technique - A Detailed Overview